November 2022

S M T W T F S
  123 45
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
27282930   

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Thursday, April 22nd, 2004 11:33 am
Last night I was watching Ellen (as I am wont to do) and one of her guests was John Travolta. She said something during her monologue, then he said something while she was talking to him...and the two things mated in my brain and did one of those 'resonance field' things, and I found myself having a great idea for a short story...but it sounds just familiar enough that I may have already read something similar or seen a similar story in a movie or episode of some show. Either that, or it's just such a good idea, I can't comprehend how anyone could have not had it before me.

So the premise is below. Your job: Does this sound familiar to you? Yes, I see the obvious relation to the movies "Total Recall" and "Brainstorm," but that's not what's causing the recognition-twinge.

Ellen said (paraphrased): Everyone should do what they're really good at and, eventually, someone will be willing to pay you for it. There are professional dogwalkers who walk your dogs for you if you're too busy to do it yourself....(etc.)

Travolta said (paraphrased): Everyone is so busy these days that you practically have to pay someone to live your life. "Here's $40! Go have fun for me."

So my brain goes *click*! (It was audible, and I actually didn't hear anything they said for several minutes and had to rewind ReplayTV.)

In the future, there is a company who employs people who are very good at having a good time. They party and live it up, go on fabulous vacations, do safe-but-dangerous things, etc. You can hire them to send someone on your vacation if you're too busy or, perhaps, too infirm, to go yourself. Or go to your kid's soccer game while you're at an important meeting with your boss. You can specify how much fun you're willing to have. Like, "I want to get really drunk and have illicit sex with hookers" or "I'd like to skydive out of a blimp" or "I want to scuba with sharks while wearing a raw meat helmet." Whatever. And they find someone and send them out to do whatever it is and then they come back and the experience is downloaded from their brain into yours (or perhaps into a device and then into you) and the subjective "I" of the memories becomes you, and you can even edit the memories so that the hooker is a blonde instead of a redhead, or whatever. You can see many storylines that arc off the basic premise, which is why it's so appealing to me.

I see small connections with, as I said, Total Recall, and also with Brainstorm. Maybe others, as well, but do you remember anything that this is sufficiently identical to that it would constitute plagiarism instead of inspiration? :)

I welcome any and all responses except those saying only "Yeah, it's just like Total Recall/Brainstorm." :)

[Edit: And "The Sixth Day". Just a little. :) ]
Thursday, April 22nd, 2004 03:45 pm (UTC)
Well, those two and Strange Days, yes. Also, Orson Scott Card used the memory recording/dump idea as one of the concepts in his Worthing stories.

Obviously, several authors have used the premise, so you're in no danger of plagerism there. The question is whether your plot and characters are sufficiently different from the other stories, since the SF premise has been done so many times.
Thursday, April 22nd, 2004 04:45 pm (UTC)
James Cameron's five-years-ahead peek of Turn-of-the-Century LA. Bits of it were disturbingly spot-on.
Thursday, April 22nd, 2004 03:56 pm (UTC)
It is a fairly common premise; I think even Johnny Mnemonic used it. argh. I'm remembering some scene in the end of something where a person is firmly stating the realization that the memories aren't their own. I can't remember what this was, though.
Thursday, April 22nd, 2004 04:02 pm (UTC)
David Brin's _Kiln People_ had a machine you could use to make copies of yourself that live a short time and then either disintegrate, or come home and download their memories back into the original body
Thursday, April 22nd, 2004 06:28 pm (UTC)
Pretty much anything Phil Dick ever wrote touches on the transience of the subjective perspective. Which is to say, lots of concepts about memory. Remembering, forgetting, copying, erasing, splicing, etc. Personally, to run a bit with your take on it, I could see hiring someone, having them download your impressions/likes/dislikes, then trying out something you're not sure you would enjoy, and then letting you know if you'd enjoy doing it after all. Then you could go and do it yourself, and be assured (or at least be more likely) to have a good time. Hey, imagine what that could do for dating. Two people somewhat interested in each other could hire people to go on a date for them, and let them know if they're compatible... ehh, okay, maybe that's too silly.
Friday, April 23rd, 2004 07:08 am (UTC)
She likes your idea :)

There were a few SF stories printed along this theme. About being able to pay to get what you want. These she remembers vividly, unfortunately, she's not good at remembering names, the people and the book kind.

One story goes :
People are being recruited by a mysterious organization to go out and have fun. Carte, quite blanche fun. The only condition : there has to be genuine and intense emotion generated from these activities. If the employee gets 'tired' of having fun or if the organization decides that the emotions are no longer intense and genuine, s/he stops, download his memories to the organization and would be paid oodles of money.

Second story :
Premise is Man could never get enough time to have fun. Ever person in the society work hard and try to move up a 'fun' ladder. At each rung, the person is given 'androids' that would replace humans in performing the mundane activities releasing these humans to have more fun. However, the person has to keep working to maintain his rank.

Third story :
Not exactly in line with ye idea. It's about paying people to switch body parts. Like replacing lovely young skin for wrinkly old skin, old tickers for young ones.

Would anyone happens to remember who wrote those, please? She's been trying to remember so she could find more stories of the same writers.
Friday, April 23rd, 2004 07:10 am (UTC)
Note : For the first story? There was a slight twist to the ending.